Meet the hedge fund gobbling up local newspapers

One sports business trend to watch: private equity firms led by Silver Lake and CVC are battling it out in a new kind of high-stakes competition for returns: snapping up entire sporting leagues. Go deeper here

Want more on the industry? Try our Scoreboard newsletter, which is produced in conjunction with the DD team and delivered every Saturday morning. Get in on the action here.

New Zealand’s players perform the haka before the Japan 2019 Rugby World Cup bronze final match in Tokyo © AFP via Getty Images

Welcome to the Due Diligence briefing from the Financial Times. Not a subscriber to DD? Sign up here. Drop us a line and join the conversation: 

‘Destroyer of newspapers’ or guardian angel? A hedge fund’s local journalism spree

Stories about the ailing newspaper business usually feature fabulously wealthy benefactors asserting good intentions as the heroes keeping the lights on. 

There’s Jeff Bezos and The Washington Post, biotech billionaire Patrick Soon-Shiong and the Los Angeles Times, and Laurene Powell Jobs, the widow of Steve Jobs and the majority owner of The Atlantic.

But as the FT’s Anna Nicolaou and DD’s James Fontanella-Khan report, today about half of America’s newspapers are controlled by private equity, hedge funds and other investment groups after getting caught in the post-2008 financial crisis spin cycle of consolidation.

And one name stands above the rest: Alden Global Capital. The New York hedge fund is notoriously private, as reflected by the particular barrenness of its website

However, Alden and its president Heath Freeman have received attention from US officials, labour unions, media watchdogs and disgruntled journalists for its swelling portfolio of local papers, of which the firm routinely whittles down with a brutally efficient “zero-based budgeting” strategy, straight from the playbook of Wall Street’s most-feared activists.

Heath Freeman, president of Alden Global Capital

Alden had approached Tribune about buying out the entire company, in an offer valuing the publisher of the Chicago newspaper at $520m, a public filing revealed  © Bloomberg

Alden has become the “personification of the new vulture capitalism that has invaded what was once, not long ago, a business that cared about its mission and its civic role”, said media industry analyst Ken Doctor.

Some employees of his companies and bankers who have cut deals with him refer to Freeman as the “destroyer of newspapers”, a name fitting for the trail of “ghost newspapers” Alden has left in its wake, a term coined by critics to describe publications stuffed with adverts and wire copy, but void of original journalism, after years of budget cuts.

Freeman doesn’t see it that way, though. “It’s important for people to understand that we actually try saving many newspapers from extinction. And put them on a path to sustainability,” he wrote to the FT in an email, via his public relations adviser.

READ  'It's all about money' – Michael Jackson's family slam documentary

A spokesperson for MNG, the holding company controlled by Alden, told the FT: “It’s a lot easier to make snippy anonymous comments than actually undertake the difficult task of making sure news organisations across America are able to serve their communities during a prolonged period of declining revenues.”

Newsroom employment has been in steep decline since 2008, number of US newsroom employees (’000)  … with newspapers bearing the brunt of media losses, newsroom employees by industry (’000)

It’s also important to highlight that Alden Capital didn’t invent the ghost paper trade. Small and midsized regional and local newspapers have long been treated as a distressed asset class, bounced around by investors for short-term profits. 

Fortress Investment Group, which is controlled by SoftBank, and Chatham Asset Management, the firm run by former Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley banker Anthony Melchiorre, are challenging Alden for a spot on the throne.

Now, with its sights set on Tribune Publishing, which owns revered papers such as the Hartford Courant and the Chicago Tribune, Freeman’s critics and competitors alike await his next move.

Has the Fed broken the stock market?

There’s an old fable that tells us if you put a frog in boiling water it will jump out, but if you put it in warm water and slowly turn the heat up, the frog will boil to death. 

This is where Seth Klarman, the founder of the hedge fund Baupost Group, thinks investors are. The Federal Reserve is turning up the heat and its dovish monetary policies have “lit the stock market on fire”.

Seth Klarman, president of Baupost Group © Bloomberg

The value investor, who is often compared to Warren Buffett, vented his frustrations in a private letter to clients seen by DD’s Ortenca Aliaj and Eric Platt. The “800-pound gorilla,” as he likes to refer to the Fed, has been throwing its weight around and taking up room where investors such as Klarman would normally participate in financial markets. 

To put it simply, Klarman thinks investors have become too complacent about risks and the Fed’s policies are largely to blame. He is effectively telling us that the market is broken. 

Here are some quotes from the letter to explain why:

  • In reference to the Fed’s expanding balance sheet: “These policies and programmes have directly contributed to exceptionally benign market conditions where nearly everything is bid up while downside volatility is truncated. The market’s usual role in price discovery has effectively been suspended”.

  • “At lower rates, it has seemingly come to pass that the more debt the country takes on, the less it costs to fund. We expect, in due course, that this shall prove unsustainable… ”

  • “When it comes to the value of cash flows, the vast and limitless future, yet to unfold, has gained considerable ground on the more firmly anchored present.”

  • “When the Fed goes on offence, there appears to be neither a need to play defence nor any possible reward for it.”

  • “Investors, facing the certainty of subpar returns on liquid investments, are committing an act of faith by betting that going-in valuations of venture and private equity deals don’t matter, interest rates will never go up, and the economy won’t stumble. But it’s easier these days for investors to project recent trends to the sky than to stand alone believing otherwise.”

READ  BBC women's group calls for action to tackle racism and sexism

Private equity benefits from being extremely online

Leveraged buyouts of traditional retailers have not gone well for big private equity shops. 

Ecommerce plays have, unsurprisingly, turned out better. The mix of the two has been volatile to say the least.

On Thursday MyTheresa, the online luxury retailer once part of department store chain Neiman Marcus, debuted its shares, which soared, sending its equity value to almost $3bn.

NYSE president Stacey Cunningham applauds as MyTheresa chief Michael Kliger virtually rings the opening bell at the New York Stock Exchange on Thursday © AP

Neiman bought MyTheresa in 2014 for just $200m. As the FT chronicled last year, the ecommerce site was the central focus of the ugly 2020 Neiman bankruptcy in which creditors alleged that the company and its private equity owners, Ares Management and Canada’s CPPIB, had improperly snatched the online unit from creditors. 

That case was settled between a junior creditor group and Ares/CPPIB, where the latter ceded $172m worth of MyTheresa securities to trade claimants and junior bondholders without admitting wrongdoing. (A hedge fund manager, Dan Kamensky, was separately arrested by the FBI over allegations of fraud, extortion and obstruction of justice in the midst of all the chaos.)

Today MyTheresa is owned both by the Ares consortium as well as previous creditors of Neiman, all of whom must be thrilled at today’s public market reception (Ares had said in 2020 that creditor valuations of MyTheresa at $900m were “astronomically high” and had “no resemblance to reality”).

Still, MyTheresa has a long way to reach the heights of Chewy, one of the biggest ecommerce success stories in a record year for online shopping.

BC Partners’ multi-billionaire dollar buyout of PetSmart was floundering just a few years ago, but the pet supplies chain and BC teamed up to make a similar online bet on pet e-retailer Chewy in 2016. After settling creditor allegations of asset-stripping, the website went public and today has a market capitalisation exceeding a staggering $40bn.

READ  Marilyn Manson removed from US TV shows following abuse allegations

MyTheresa’s online offerings seem to be off to a good start, though, if the $510 Moncler dog gilet available for purchase is any indication.

Job moves

  • EG Group, the UK petrol stations company whose billionaire owners are buying supermarket chain Asda, has appointed retail veteran Stuart Rose as its new chairman to improve governance after its auditors resigned over the matter last year.

  • Skadden Arps has hired Raquel Fox as a member of the firm’s SEC reporting and compliance practice. She previously served as a senior adviser to SEC chairman Jay Clayton.

  • The US Treasury Department has made a series of senior hires. You can view them here.

  • The UK Takeover Panel has appointed former Slaughter and May senior partner Chris Saul as the new chair of its code committee, replacing Richard Murley ahead of his retirement. Michael Hatchard, a former partner at Skadden Arps, will also join the panel in May as a member of the hearings committee.

  • Tate & Lyle has recruited Vivid Sehgal as its new finance chief effective in May. He replaces Imran Nawaz who is departing to become chief financial officer of Tesco.

Smart reads

Jack is back The Chinese billionaire is back after a mysterious three-month disappearance from public view, but not necessarily with a vengeance. (FT)

Fannie and Freddie’s fumble With Donald Trump in power, hedge funds rolled the dice on the privatisation of the US mortgage-finance giants. That option now seems off the table and the likes of Bill Ackman and John Paulson are feeling the burn. (Wall Street Journal)

Silicon Valley hits at Hollywood’s wallets The movie business rewards stars and A-list directors when films smash it at the box office. But in a world of shuttered cinemas and straight-to-streaming, technology companies are the ones raking in the extra cash. (Bloomberg)

News round-up

JPMorgan keeps Dimon’s pay steady at $31.5m for 2020 (BBG) 

Listed private capital: Dyal it up (Lex) 

IG agrees to buy US rival Tastytrade for $1bn (FT) 

Third Spac ETF launch taps into blank-cheque company boom (WSJ) 

Two former Julius Baer chief executives reprimanded by Swiss regulator (FT)

VW hit with fines for missing strict EU emissions targets (FT) 

Beckhams pay themselves healthy dividend even as losses deepen (FT) 

Cineworld facing revolt over proposed £65m CEO bonus scheme (FT)



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here